Category Archives: Essays

Features and essays

Nail Biter

tempest in District 3First, what exactly is a tempest in a teapot? Basically, it’s froth. It simmers, it bubbles, it boils, but the heat is contained in a small vessel, and in the end serves up little more than a modest cup of tea. This is how I think we should assess the “concession” drama in the District 3 council race. First, a reporter wrote excitedly that candidate Ellen Cochrane, a surprisingly strong contender, had conceded. She had dropped to third place and in a post to supporters she sounded as if she had done the math. She had. But she did not concede.

A voter called her. “My wife says you didn’t concede, but I want to be sure,” he said. She told him she didn’t, and wouldn’t till all votes were in. Others asked the same or similar questions and she gave the same answer. Still others called to tell her they refuted the concession rumor. My question is this: why didn’t the Bee reporter who wrote the article call her first to check the facts? He is paid to ascertain accuracy. He could have picked up the phone and clarified the issue permanently. Instead he assembled a story based on assumptions.

He did return her call when she called the Bee editorial department, then left him a message from Hawaii. “If you weren’t sure about my intentions, why didn’t you contact me?” she asked. His answer was that he discussed the matter with colleagues, political consultants, and someone from the News and Review. Now. Is it persnickety to suggest that News and Review colleagues might know a bit less about a subject than the subject herself?

More years ago than it is polite to tell, I took a few college journalism courses from Ms. Miriam Young, a fastidious lady with a mitigated Texas drawl. Ms. Young would tolerate no shortcuts. “Go to the source, go to the source, go to the source,” she would say. Our reporter might have profited from that class. The old fundamentals still apply: go to the source. Was the candidate premature in her statement? Yes, decidedly. Hers was an unsophisticated, issue-oriented, grass-roots campaign funded entirely by small donors who were District 3 neighbors and property owners. She had no high-paid consultants to advise her about political protocol or strategy. She was not part of the insider city bureaucracy. But the concession tempest is not the big story of her campaign.

The big story is this. Though she entered too late to secure endorsements, she made neighborhood preservation and quality of life prominent issues. She had a brave idea. She had gumption. She had a small team who believed in her, and trusted her vision. She answered questions frankly, then explained how she arrived at her conclusions. She didn’t dodge, duck or equivocate. One woman said, “I never met a politician like you before.” Neither had we. We liked the candidate she became: a principled advocate for the under-represented, a force for a clean vote and ethical politics. A great many people from East Sacramento, River Park and South Natomas responded to this and supported her. How she pulled this off in an election where developers finance candidacies and the traditional media anoint themselves kingmakers is the real story. The big headline from District 3 should read, Neighbors Have Champion. Everything else is a tempest in a teapot.

Pat Lynch

Posted in Essays | Comments Off on Nail Biter

Courtship

SONY DSCIn prodigious bulk they come—the mailers. Day after day—large, sleek, colorful, pictures and text on shiny cardstock. In the beginning I marveled at their abundance, and, like most, tossed them in the recycle. But after a time I began to read them. Within a day I was addicted. I began putting them aside so I could read batches at once. It was like taping Madmen for binge viewing. You should try this. Stack them somewhere, pour yourself a drink, put your feet up, and surrender. You’re being courted, and quite gallantly. That little vote of yours has made you a catch.

The most ardent of our wooers is Dr. Pan. He comes calling every day, sometimes more than once. House calls are back. He nearly always wears his white coat and his stethoscope. He’s a pediatrician so if you have young kids Dr. Pan will high-five them. He is frequently pictured with a cute little girl who seems bizarrely happy to be going to the doctor. It makes you think back. We didn’t have a fun Dr. Pan when we were kids. We had Dr. Koch, a nice enough man, but he always shone that light right into our eyes. Once I upchucked on his shoe.

Another big Dr. Pan mailer features a giant close-up of a baby with a glop of yellow goo on his lip. “Dr. pan, I could use a little help,” the text states.  I don’t think this is a successful ad because the wet, runny, yellow glop dissuaded me from opening the pamphlet. So I don’t know what Dr. Pan is going to do to dry that child’s face. But no matter, Dr. Pan comes every day. He’s on the job. You have to admit that his barrage is working because now we know his name. This is a holiday and I actually sort of miss him, and am looking forward to his next visit.

Then there’s the sandwich. I have to say, I was gob-smacked by this one. It’s a close-up of a big Philly cheese sandwich. The candidate is quoted saying his first job was making these at a mall. Now, how is that sandwich going to win votes? Someone said that the plan was to trick voters into thinking it was a coupon, then turn the sandwich over to see the candidate’s parents smiling fondly upon him. But that’s a stupid idea, because what if you found no coupon and became irate? Or what if you’re a vegan and here comes this big, meat-dripping, cheesy sandwich through your mail slot? What can those consultants have been thinking? I know a candidate whose first job was sweeping up in a hair salon. How about a picture of a floor covered with different snips of human hair—hair of all styles, colors and texture to show diversity? Not a good idea? I agree. But that doesn’t mean it won’t happen.

A hit piece on Roger Dickenson is also kind of loony. The first thing you see is a pink memo page with Dickenson’s name in red, a red X near it. So you think the X means  Vote for Dickenson. Wrong. The piece asserts that Dickenson spends too much time away from Sacramento, but you never get to the message because you’ve been led astray by the red X. Then there’s the dark PAC mailer with the BIG RED EYE. Yes, it’s a full-page eyeball spewing red. The pupil is shaped like California. In case you still don’t get it, the text shouts, “They’re eyeing California.” Who’s eyeing California? Lift the dark flap and there’s our own Dr. Pan and, gasp, head-shots of the Koch brothers. Stacks of hundred dollar bills sit beneath Dr. Pan’s perpetually grinning face. So the doctor has finally made it—he’s familiar enough to be vilified by association. Unless, of course, you like the Koch brothers. It’s all a gamble.

Teachers are in this year. Many candidates claim teaching experience, though I expect few have an actual credential and served time in the classroom. But here’s one Assembly aspirant posing before a blackboard. To help you realize it’s a blackboard the words, Reading, Math, Science and Art are chalked on it, along with an algebra problem, a molecule and a big A+. Open it and there’s John F. Kennedy’s face taking up the whole of the left interior. “Leadership and learning are indispensable,” Kennedy announces. The rest of the mailer is logical but Kennedy was a surprise. He seemed plucked from the ether and planted on the page.

A real teacher has a worse ad. He wants to be Superintendent of Public Instruction and has that golden credential and relevant qualifications. But his lead photo shows a young woman amid four kids. “You’ve Been Here…Have They?” the text asks, showing a partiality for capital letters. But who’s You? Who are They? I had to open the whole thing and consult with others before being satisfied that the You was the teacher candidate, The Here was the classroom, and the They was his opponent. But his named opponent is merely one man. How can one man be a They? There’s an A+ pictured on this document too, but I’m giving it a D for lack of clarity and subject-pronoun confusion.

There’s an interesting race between Maggie Krell and Anne Marie Schubert for District Attorney. The Bee likes Schubert, the Guv likes Krell. Both have serviceable mailers but Krell says she’ll cut her own salary, so that promises an interesting final week of pledges and counter-pledges. This last week will be nice for all of us who await the postman’s blizzard of oddities. It’s cool to be courted by mail, cool to be desirable and important before we fade back into that neglected anonymous mass they call the public.

Pat Lynch

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in Essays | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Courtship